The Historama Alex Ben-Arieh P.O.Box 32128 Tel Aviv, Israel 61321 Phone: +972-547-680-086 Fax: +972-3-546-1971 |
Independence Day 1948 "The Most Crowded Hours in... History" Based on the account by Dan Kurzman in "Genesis 1948" and interweaving details from other sources Music: "The Pillar of Fire" by Shem-Tov Levy (3:26 min) |
Solemnity and open-collared shirts: David Ben-Gurion reads the Israeli Declaration of Independence, 4pm on 14th May 1948 |
Israeli President, Shimon Peres, gave a speech now on the occasion of Israel's 60th anniversary in which he praised the Israeli trait of "chutzpah" - insolent audacity - as the creative spirit behind the country's progress and advancement in all fields of life. The Israeli character is one of creativeness mixed with impatience; professionalism matched by a gross lack of formality, which sometimes cuts to the chase and yields rewards - and sometimes gets bogged down in morass and misunderstanding. The story of Israel's day of independence in 1948 is a picture perfect moment of the Israeli character, capturing the apex of one of our times most important historical events, brought about by the Israeli, yet set against a chaotic backdrop of preparation and strife in which this character must struggle and advance forth. |
The hourglass was running: with the Mandate due to expire in 24 hours, the Jewish leadership had to decide how to fill the oncoming vacuum in authority - to declare independence over the allotted Jewish territory or not, but if so, then what to declare at all? Against this backdrop, on the eve of Thursday the 13th of May, Otto Wallisch, the Czech-born artist was approached by Ze'ev Sharif, in charge of the Independence Day arrangements, to have a place prepared for the event. It would take place at the Tel Aviv Museum on 16 Rothschild Boulevard in Tel Aviv: "You must have the auditorium ready within twenty-four hours. The state will be declared there. And remember, this is top secret!" The Jewish people had struggled for close to 2000 years to return to the Land of Israel and re-establish their home. And now the Zionist leadership wanted to have a declaration of independence ceremony ready in less than 24 hours. And Sharef imposed a further toll on Wallisch: "Not more than a hundred and fifty Pounds [$450] in expenses, eh?" Such was the state of affairs that the State-to-be did not yet have an agreed upon name. Wallisch, who had poster designs to his name and created Israel's first banknotes and stamps, had just completed the designs of her first stamp series - only that in the absence of an approved name for the State-to-be, future Israel's first stamps bore the name "Hebrew Post" ('Doar Ivri') as the name "Israel" for the new state was not yet a guaranteed certainty. = = = And in the meantime, the founding fathers of the state were still hammering out their positions on the actual declaration itself. Only a day before (the 12th) the leading figure of the Zionist movement and Jewish community in Palestine, David Ben-Gurion, had succeeded in convincing the ruling council (the People's Administration - "Minhelet Ha'am") to agree to a declaration of independence at all - and that on a majority of one vote. Now he and the other 12 members of the Administration had to address ultimate issues of Synagogue and State in less than 24 hours, with each trying to insert his own view or personality into the historical document. An argument broke out over whether to define the new State's frontiers: Ben-Gurion apposed the idea. Citing the American Declaration of Independence, he said "It contains no mention of territorial limits… The Arabs are making war on us. If we beat them, the western part of the Galilee and the territory on both sides of the road to Jerusalem will become part of the State. Why tie ourselves down?" His view prevailed. But then arose the question of G-d's role in the State's establishment. Mercifully - almost miraculously - the argument lasted only two hours, with Ben-Gurion mediating a debate on the issue of whether to refer to G-d as the "G-d of Israel", "the Almighty and Redeemer of Israel" or whether to ignore Him altogether. Ben-Gurion, an atheist socialist, proposed the phrase "Rock of Israel" - and succeeded, making one faction believe it referred to G-d while convincing the other that it didn't. And then came the argument over the name of the State-to-be. One member requested the name "Judea", but others pointed out that this Biblical name only referred to one region within the prospective state. Others proposed the name "Zion", citing the benefit of the Jews in having the last word at the United Nations and other international forums since they would be voting at the end of the alphabetical list. But others argued that "Zion" was also the name of a hill, and that this might be confusing. Ben-Gurion suggested the name "Israel", and at the last moment this name was approved. The Declaration was then penned by the future foreign minister, Moshe Sharett, whose version was then re-edited that night by Ben-Gurion, who replaced the formal flowery language with a stronger more assertive tone, and deleting the word "Whereas" from the beginning of each paragraph. Sharett never quite lived down the editorial changes to "his" historic document. Meanwhile, Wallisch was in a panic: he had to organize the event before sundown - for 4pm - the following day, Friday, for if the ceremony ran late into the start of the Sabbath, no Jewish leader would sign the Declaration (as this would be against religious custom on a Sabbath). |
The Tel Aviv Museum on Rothschild Street on the day of the Declaration, 1948 |
The Tel Aviv Museum as it appears today, 2008 Commemorate plaque at the Museum entrance |
Across Palestine, Jews and Arabs tuned into the secret station broadcasting the proclamation, although in Jerusalem only the first portion was heard: the Arab Legion halted its bombardment of the Jewish sector for afternoon tea, but then renewed the firing such that no one managed to hear the rest of the broadcast. The event consisted of three parts: the reading of the Declaration itself and the signing of the Council members' names to it; the first decrees of the new government; and the playing of the national anthem. Hidden on an upper story was the Palestine [momentarily to be "Israel"] Philharmonic Orchestra, under Leonard Bernstein's conductorship. When the declaration ceremony was over the Orchestra played the Jewish national anthem "Ha'Tikva" ("The Hope"), which became the Israeli national anthem and probably the first time it was played following the Declaration of Independence. Ben-Gurion declared the session officially over at 4:38pm, and when the the participants were leaving the building, Ben-Gurion surging with pride turned to a British reporter and exclaimed, "You see, we did it!" A little earlier that same day, across the ocean in the United States, the President, Harry Truman, decided to prepare to recognize the Jewish State for when it would be declared, and requested that his government receive a formal request by the Jews for recognition of statehood. The representative of the Jewish people in Palestine, the representative of the "Jewish Agency for Palestine", in the United States found himself in the awkward position of being asked if his people would still declare their independence, and if so, to please submit a request to be recognized. The representative had to ask a US State Department colleague coyly what to do about requesting recognition for a country whose name had not yet been determined. The State Department official suggestion using the United Nations designation for the territory - "Jewish State", and so the official request by the Jews of the United States for recognition read as thus: |
= = = History caught up with minute details of procedure: just a few moments after this letter was dispatched to the White House, news of the actual declaration of Independence - and the official name of the new state - reached the ears of the Jewish Agency's representatives. In a hurry, one of them dashed to the White House and met up with the dispatcher in time to have the real name of the State penned out and replaced by the name "State of Israel" (see photo above). A short while later, 11 minutes after Israel declared her independence, the Agency representatives were informed by the White House, "Thanks for the letter. We'll recognize you, but keep it strictly confidential." The excited representative then realized that he couldn't even inform his own government by phone, as it as yet lacked a code system. When the session for the Declaration ended, news arrived that the Western Galilee had been conquered by Jewish forces. At dawn the following day, the 15th, the armies of six Arab nations invaded Israel and the War of Independence entered its second phase. With Tel Aviv under aerial bombardment, Ben-Gurion addressed American radio listeners ("They want me to speak to America? Tell them it's okay. I'll do it.") in New York on a live 5am address to them. History was also postponed by procedure too: being the Sabbath now, by Jewish tradition no form of labor could be performed; as such, the Hebrew press could only official splutter the good news in the few hours left before sundown, and so the full announcement of the establishment of the State really took place two days later, on Sunday the 16th, when the Jewish working week officially began. |
Contents of the Declaration: the declaration is a short document comprising five main elements - a historical summary, the Declaration of Independence, legal decrees of authority in the newly established State, statements of purpose for the newly established State, and calls to the various external bodies for assistance and cooperation. The document begins with a summary of Jewish history from Biblical times to the present day then (1948). In outlining this Jewish history the document also ties the origins and development of the Jews to the Land of Israel ("Eretz Israel" in Zionist/Hebrew parlance), and interweaves moral, historical and legal justifications to the Jewish claim to Israel - specifically the Balfour Declaration (1927) and the United Nations Resolution of 1947 to partition Palestine. The Declaration also documents the deeds and accomplishments of the Jewish people for themselves (in the rebuilding of Eretz Israel in the last century) and for the world around around them (the gift of the Bible) in order to position the demand for Independence as a matter of course for an established nation. In this area the document is unique for in spite of its prophetic importance it unflinchingly mentions names, dates and events without the vagueness and flowery grandeur that may be expected from a document of this stature (compare this to the United States Declaration of Independence for an albeit much older example) - "Eternal Book of Books" and "Rock of Israel" are the rare instances of formal language used in the Declaration. The document mentions the "Nazi" evil twice; personally invokes the name of Theodore Herzl (by his original first name and not by "Benjamin Zeev", his Hebraicized name); mentions the "Zionist Movement" and "Zionist Congress"; the "Second World War" and the "Holocaust"; the "United Nations"; the "bloody attacks" by the Arabs in the then present struggle. It is both a timeless and a contemporary document in its choice of words and nouns. The historical and legal synopsis of the document culminates in to the actual Declaration itself, the 11th paragraph squarely positioned at the center of the document, in larger, bolder letters. In this paragraph the new State is declared as the "State of Israel". The following paragraph is a remarkable deliniation of the immediate arragements for governance in the new State of Israel, statements akin to the contents of the American Constitution. A very dry and technical section, dates are established for when and how the national authorities will be established: until 1 October 1948 the existing People's Council will become a temporary "National Council", and het executive arm, the People's Administration will function as the temporary Government; by 1 October the existing Legislating Assembly will establish the laws by which to create elected and permanent authorities in the State. Remarkably too, this paragraph reiterates a little differently the name of the State as "Israel" and not "State of Israel" In the next two paragraphs the Declaration opens the gates of the new State to Jewish immigration in a concrete statement of intention but also presents its altruistic aims to be a nation of equality and freedom. It separately declares the intention to cooperate with the United Nations in fulfillment of its 1947 partition resolution. The final paragraphs of the Declaration are a series of calls to intergovernmental bodies, the neighboring Arab states, Israel's own Arab residents, and the Jewish diaspora to cooperate with the new State and help bring about peace in the region. Ironically, though not Arab, Iran (Persia) did recognize Israel just hours hereafter. Of note, in its closing paragraph, where the assembled leaders commit to sign their names to the Declaration, only here is G-d's name mentioned (once) and then only in the phrase "Rock of Israel" (for more about the then and ongoining disagreements about the Declaration's content, see this article). The names on the Declaration are those of the 38 members of the People's Council ("Moetzet Ha'Am"), now referred to in the text as the "temporary National Council", as designated in the 12th 'legalistic' paragraph. The names were signed in alphabetical order though with Ben-Gurion's nevertheless being the first. And of the 38 members, only 26 were actually present to sign their names on May 14th, as the others were abroad or stranded in beseiged Jerusalem: space was made for their names on the parchment sheet and they signed their names afterwards. Presentation of the Declaration: there is also something to be said about the manner in which the Declaration was read by Ben-Gurion - it is a "declaration" in every sense: his tone is declarative and assertive if 'angry' in certain portions of the document. Listening to him read the Declaration one senses a striking lack of gushing emotion; he is not caught up in the headiness of the moment and remains firmly in control of his voice. In places he ennunciates words syllable by syllable as if to not miss stressing the words. Ben-Gurion's tone is cold, flat and harsh - unapologetic - as if closing an account with history itself. At the moment of the actual statement of the Declaration of Independence there is a full half minute of unmitigated applause - 2000 years of exile and struggle sealed and closed in those 30 seconds of rapture. The document sweepingly summarizes the events which led up to the decision to declare independence and then set forth as a new State: 12 short minutes, with just 6 to reach the climactic moment of the statement of the Declaration itself. A remarkable document in its breadth, depth - and brevity. |
David Ben-Gurion presents the Founding Charter; Council Members sign the document (17:09 min) Click to play the simultaneous recording David Ben-Gurion: "I will read before you the Founding Charter of the State of Israel, which has been approved in its first reading by the People's Council:" |
Ben-Gurion: "We will stand to receive the Founding Charter of the State of Israel" [attendees rise] Rabbi Yehuda Leib HaCohen Fishman Maimon, leader of the religious Zionist movement and Minister of Religious Affairs in the new government, recites the "She'heckiyanu" blessing. The blessing thanks G-d for sustaining the lives of the utterers so they could experience that moment in their lives. For the religious the blessing is a reminder that that life is a gift from G-d, a reminder to experience the joy of the moment and to cherish blessings. The blessing is recited to express appreciation for new or special experiences in the utterer's life. "Blessed are You, Lord our G-d, King of the universe, who has kept us alive, and sustained us, and enabled us to reach this moment. [Amen]" Ben-Gurion: "All members of the People's Council who are in Jerusalem, which to my regret were not able to gather here for reasons known, convened at the offices of the Jewish Agency and notified us that they join us as a single voice in their support of this Declaration. Now, members of the People's Council are asked, according to the [alphabetical] order, to come forth as they are called. The secretary of the People's Council will call out the names and everyone will sign his name on the Founding Charter. The names of the members in Jerusalem will be read out according to the order." The Secretary: "Mr. David Ben-Gurion..." Ben-Gurion: "Here? Here?" The Secretary: "Yes, yes" [applause] "Writing" History: One of the signatories, Dr. Rosenblum, in time the chief editor of the daily newspaper "Yediot Achronot", recounted years later that Ben-Gurion and Moshe Shertok, the future first Foreign Minister, each stood on either side of the Scroll during the signings, and that Ben-Gurion had convinced Rosenblum to sign his name on the Charter using his pen name: "When I rose to the dais, Ben-Gurion turned to me and in a firm voice said, "sign as 'Vardi' and not as 'Rosenblum'". I didn't know why I had to sign by the name Vardi, which was my pen name at the newspaper, but I signed as asked. And that's how my name remained in the Independence Scroll, and many don't know until today who that is. In one of my opportunities I asked Ben-Gurion what was his motive and the answer I received was that he wanted as many Hebrew names as possible in the Scroll." Another person who Ben-Gurion tried to Hebraicize was Zerach Warhaftig, in time the Religious Affairs Minister. Warhaftig refused the request to sign under the name "Amitai" ('Warhaftig' derives from the German word for 'Truth') under the objection that nobody would know who that is. Another signatory, who muddled up his name a bit on his own initiative in the Scroll was Saadia Kobashi, the representative of the Yemenite community, who signed his name as "S. Kobashi" and added the word "Ha'Levy", in order to denote that he was from the Levite tribe, something which later caused everyone to search out who this seemingly anonymous signatory was. The rest of the names are read out as "Mister" or "The Right Honorable..." ("Ha'Adon" or "Ha'Giveret"); absent members, stuck in besieged Jerusalem or abroad in New York, are mentioned so THE SIGNATORIES as they appear signed on the Charter (absent signatories are marked by me with an "*"):
|
David Ben-Gurion announces new legal decrees and revocation of the 1939 White Book (2:50 min) Click to play the simultaneous recording "By authority of this Declaration of Independence which was published today, 5th of Eiyar 5708, according to which were established the temporary National Council ["Moetzet Ha'Medina"] and the temporary Government of the State of Israel, does the temporary Nation Council hereby declare the following: A. The temporary National Council is the legislating authority. The temporary National Council is authorized to extend this right to the temporary Government for the purpose of creating legislation and law. B. The provisions of the law which derive from the White Book of the year 1939 are hereby null and void [applause]. The sections 13 to 15 of the Immigration Order of 1941, and the regulations 102 to 107G of the Defence Regulations (for Emergency Period) of 1945 are hereby repudiated [applause]. Regulations for the Transfer of Land of 1940 are hereby repudiated retroactively as of the day 29th Iyar 5699, 18 May 1939 [applause]. C. As long as new laws are not issued by the temporary National Council or according to her wishes, there will remain in effect in the State of Israel the law which existed in Eretz Israel on day 5th Iyar 5708, 14th of May 1948. In as much as possible that the matter stands in conformity with the contents of this proclamation, with the laws of the future and those transformed as a result of the establishment of the State and her Authorities, is this proclamation handed down today, 5th Iyar 5708, 14th of May 1948, by the temporary National Council." |
The Israeli Philharmonic Orchestra plays the national anthem at the close of the ceremony (1:45 min)
Click to play the simultaneous recording |
More materials will be added shortly: on the different versions of the Scroll which exist and on the recorded interviews made with signatories, in 1960. |
BIBLIOGRAPHY: Erez, Yaakov and Ilan Kfir; "Tzahal in its Success: Encyclopedia of the Army and Security, Vol. 1"; Revivim Publishers, 1982 Haber, Eitan: "The First Immigrant" op-ed in Yediot Achronot, 4.11.2007, p. 29 Kurzman, Dan; "Genesis 1948"; Sefer ve Sefel Publishing, Jerusalem, 2005 "Meet: The First Independence Scroll" by Goel Beno in Yediot Achronot, 31.10.2007, p. 14 Music Disk: "Music From Films", Shem-Tov Levy; Hed Arzi Music; 1995 Original Declaration Recordings from the disk: "We Hereby Declare..." edited by Eran Litvin; Hed Arzi Music; 2007 Stone, I. F.; "This is Israel"; Boni and Gaer Publishers, New York, 1948 "The Battle over the Independence Scroll" by Goel beno in Yediot Achronot, 25.10.2007, p. 15 "The Tzahal Album", Gershon Rivlin ed.; Maarachot Publishers, Tel Aviv, 1958 "We Hereby Sign" (Heinenu Khotmim Be'Zot), Eti Abramov, "Saturday Supplement" of Yediot Achronot, 2.05.2008, p. 24-25 |